Another classic legislative battle is brewing in California. A bill has been introduced in CA that would raise the loan limit of a payday loan to $500. It is currently $300. The other side of the argument…well, they aren’t in favor.
Rick Jurgens of the San Francisco Public Press recently did an article that raised several solid points in favor of the the payday industry. It starts with the following scenario. A client takes out a $300 loan, in which they receive $255. The lender withholds a $45 fee. The APR on this is 459%.
Greg Larsen, a spokesman for the California Financial Service Providers Association, a trade group of check-cashers and payday lenders, said that using an APR was an “apples to oranges” measure of the cost of a payday loan. “People don’t use the product for 52 consecutive weeks,” he said.
Several customers they talked to had not taken out a payday loan, but said they would consider it if they needed to. They cited the ease of obtaining one as the primary reason. The difficulty of a bank loan was brought up by one interviewee.
Larsen went on to point out that consumers “will always find credit that is the most cost effective,” when offered a choice. Others in the industry acknowledge that for most customers price is a secondary consideration. Convenience and ease are the driving forces.
Consumer Advocates say payday loans are targeted to people who can least afford them. They say it creates a cycle of debt that they are unable to get out of. Industry insiders say that the loans are vital for “cash strapped borrowers.”
A payday loan is a “convenient, short-term financial option” that provides “a fix for families faced with the prospect of bouncing checks, shutting off utilities or worse, skimping on basic needs such as medical emergencies,” according to written comments submitted by the California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce to the state Senate’s Judiciary Committee.
It’s safe to say that the back and forth on the issue will continue for as long as the loans are around.